Unfair Labour Practices: The Disputes That Happen Before Dismissal

⚑ Quick answer
An unfair labour practice under the LRA is unfair employer conduct short of dismissal, in six categories: unfair conduct relating to promotion, demotion, probation, or training; unfair suspension or other disciplinary action short of dismissal; failure to reinstate after an agreement; and unfair conduct relating to benefits. Employees refer these to the CCMA within 90 days, where the remedy is usually compensation or an order to correct the conduct. For employers, the pattern to avoid is arbitrariness: decisions about people’s careers made without criteria, process or reasons.

Not every CCMA dispute is a dismissal. The unfair labour practice jurisdiction covers the unfair things that happen while the employment continues β€” the promotion that went to the owner’s nephew, the unpaid suspension invented on the spot, the probation extended without explanation. These disputes are quieter than dismissals but nearly as common, and the employer mistakes behind them are remarkably consistent.

Unfair labour practices β€” promotion, demotion, suspension and benefits disputes for employers
Unfair Labour Practices: The Disputes That Happen Before Dismissal
πŸ“Œ Key takeaways
  • βœ”Unfair labour practices are workplace unfairness short of dismissal.
  • βœ”Six categories: promotion, demotion, probation, training, suspension/discipline, benefits.
  • βœ”The CCMA referral window is 90 days from the act or omission.
  • βœ”Suspension without pay as ‘discipline’ is the classic losing case.
  • βœ”Criteria, process and reasons β€” documented β€” are the whole defence.

The six categories of unfair labour practice

  • Promotion: unfair conduct in promotion decisions β€” bypassing criteria, predetermined outcomes, advertising a role that was never really open.
  • Demotion: reducing rank, status or responsibility without fair reason or process β€” including ‘restructures’ aimed at one person.
  • Probation: unfair conduct relating to probation β€” extending it without good reason or process, or treating the probationer in bad faith (probation rules).
  • Training: unfair denial of training the employer provides to comparable employees.
  • Suspension and discipline short of dismissal: unfair suspension β€” especially unpaid precautionary suspension, or suspension that drags on without a hearing β€” and unfair disciplinary penalties.
  • Benefits: unfair conduct about contractual benefits β€” bonuses, medical aid, allowances applied selectively or withdrawn arbitrarily.

The common thread commissioners look for is arbitrariness: a decision affecting someone’s livelihood made without criteria, without process, without reasons β€” or made for reasons that would embarrass the employer if read aloud. Fair process, it turns out, is not only for dismissals.

The 90-day window and the remedies

Unfair labour practice disputes must be referred to the CCMA within 90 days of the act or omission (or of the employee becoming aware of it). The route mirrors dismissal disputes β€” conciliation, then arbitration β€” but remedies are calibrated to the harm: compensation (typically capped at 12 months for the most serious cases), or an order correcting the conduct: reinstate the benefit, uplift the suspension, run the promotion process properly.

⚠️ Unpaid suspension is the classic own-goal
Precautionary suspension pending a hearing must be paid β€” it is not a finding of guilt. Suspending without pay as punishment, or for months without charges, hands the employee a ready-made dispute they will usually win.

It is also worth knowing what is not an unfair labour practice, because employees routinely over-claim the label. General workplace unhappiness, a manager’s brusque style, a bonus that was always discretionary and was fairly not paid, or a promotion the employee simply disagrees with β€” none of these qualify without the specific unfairness the LRA describes. The first step in defending any referral is testing whether it fits a category at all; a surprising number do not, and saying so crisply at conciliation often ends the matter there.

The employer's defence: criteria, process, reasons

  • βœ“Promotion decisions made against written criteria, with records of who applied and why the winner won
  • βœ“Demotions and role changes consulted on and agreed in writing β€” or processed properly
  • βœ“Probation extensions motivated, communicated and time-bound
  • βœ“Suspensions paid, precautionary, and followed promptly by a hearing
  • βœ“Benefits applied by policy, not by mood
  • βœ“A working grievance procedure β€” most ULP disputes die there if it is real

The grievance procedure deserves emphasis: employees with a functioning internal channel use it, and a grievance answered fairly is both the prevention and the defence. Employees without one refer to the CCMA β€” where ‘we would have fixed it if they had told us’ persuades nobody if there was no channel to tell. The wider discipline framework is in the discipline and dismissal pillar.

πŸ“š Official sources & references

Always confirm current requirements with the official source β€” rules and deadlines change.

Free tool by Admin Boss
πŸ“‹ Employment Contract Generator
Create a BCEA Section 29-compliant employment contract with instant PDF download β€” free.
Try the free tool β†’
Done-for-you by Admin Boss
Rather hand this over?
  • βœ”Admin Boss handles registrations, filings and payroll admin
  • βœ”Registered tax practitioner Β· 20+ years experience
  • βœ”Fully remote β€” all 9 provinces
Send us your question β†’Visit Admin Boss β†—πŸ“ž 074 918 7130 (Mon–Fri 08:00–16:00)

Frequently asked questions

What counts as an unfair labour practice?

Unfair employer conduct short of dismissal in six areas: promotion, demotion, probation, training, suspension or discipline short of dismissal, and benefits. The hallmark is arbitrariness β€” decisions without criteria, process or reasons.

How long does an employee have to refer an unfair labour practice?

90 days from the act or omission β€” or from when the employee became aware of it. Late referrals need condonation.

Is unpaid suspension an unfair labour practice?

Almost always, yes. Precautionary suspension pending a hearing must be paid, because it is not a finding of guilt. Unpaid suspension used as punishment β€” or suspension left hanging for months β€” is the classic losing ULP case.

Can an employee challenge a promotion decision at the CCMA?

Yes, as an unfair labour practice β€” but the CCMA does not simply substitute its preferred candidate. It intervenes where the process was unfair: criteria ignored, the outcome predetermined, or comparable candidates treated unequally. Employers who apply written criteria and keep records defend these comfortably.

AB
Written and reviewed by Andre van Niekerk β€” registered tax practitioner and founder of Admin Boss, with 20+ years helping South African businesses with SARS, CIPC and labour-department compliance.
Last reviewed: July 2026 Β· How we research our guides

EmployerGuide.online provides general information about South African employer obligations β€” not legal, tax or professional advice for your specific situation. Laws, rates and deadlines change; confirm current requirements with the official sources linked above, or ask Admin Boss. See our disclaimer.