-
Dismissing During Probation: More Latitude, Not a Free Pass
⚡ Quick answer Dismissal during probation is permitted with more latitude than after confirmation — but it is never process-free. The Code of Good Practice requires: a reasonable probation period agreed upfront, ongoing evaluation against clear standards, guidance and training where the employee falls short, a reasonable opportunity to improve, and a process where the employee can respond before the decision. Probationers are protected against unfair dismissal from day one, and against automatically unfair reasons (pregnancy, union membership) completely. ‘It is probation, I can just let them go’ is the most expensive sentence in small-business HR. Probation exists so employers can assess a new hire with some protection — and…
-
Alternatives to Retrenchment You Must Consider First (Section 189)
⚡ Quick answer Section 189 consultation must genuinely explore alternatives to retrenchment before jobs are cut: a hiring freeze, reduced hours or short-time, voluntary severance packages, early retirement, redeployment to other roles, salary sacrifices by agreement, and transferring work in-house instead of retrenching. Commissioners ask for these by name — an employer who cannot show alternatives were tabled and considered has failed the consultation, whatever the severance paid. The exploration must be documented in the consultation minutes. The question commissioners ask first in retrenchment disputes is not about severance — it is ‘what alternatives to retrenchment did you explore?’ Section 189 makes job losses a last resort, and ‘last’ is…
-
Your First CCMA Case: What to Expect, Step by Step
⚡ Quick answer A CCMA case runs: the employee refers the dispute (30 days for dismissal); you receive the referral and a set-down notice; conciliation — a private settlement meeting — happens first, and most cases settle there; if not, dismissal disputes go to arbitration, often the same day (con-arb), where the employer must prove fairness with documents and witnesses; the commissioner issues a binding award within 14 days. There is no appeal — only narrow Labour Court review. Preparation is the entire game: the discipline file built before the dispute decides most outcomes. The envelope arrives — a CCMA case, with your company named as respondent — and most…
-
Can You Dismiss for a First Offence? The Gross Misconduct Rules
⚡ Quick answer You can dismiss for a first offence in South Africa only when the misconduct is gross enough to destroy the trust relationship: theft, fraud, dishonesty, assault, gross insubordination, serious safety violations, working under the influence. Ordinary misconduct — lateness, minor policy breaches — requires progressive discipline first. And even for gross misconduct, the hearing can never be skipped: notice of charges, a chance to explain, an impartial decision. Guilt is never a substitute for process. Every employer eventually faces the first offence that feels dismissal-worthy — and the law’s answer is ‘maybe, for a short list, through a process’. Dismiss for the wrong first offence and the…
-
What a Legal Warning Letter Must Contain (South Africa)
⚡ Quick answer A warning letter that will stand up at the CCMA contains six things: the specific rule or standard breached, the facts (dates, times, what happened), the employee’s explanation (heard and recorded), the correction required, the consequence of repetition, and a validity period — typically six months for a written warning and twelve for a final written warning. It must reference a rule the employee actually knew, be signed (or refusal witnessed), and be filed. Vague warnings about ‘attitude’ are worth less than the paper. The warning letter is the atom of progressive discipline — and the document commissioners read first and most sceptically. A warning that is…
-
The COIDA 7-Day Rule: The Shortest Deadline in Employer Law
⚡ Quick answer The COIDA registration deadline is 7 days from your first employee’s start date — the shortest registration deadline in South African employer law. Section 80 of COIDA requires every employer, including households, to register with the Compensation Fund within that window. In practice: start the registration when the offer is accepted, not after the start date. Late registration is fixable (back-assessments plus penalties), but an injury in the gap is the scenario to avoid — the Fund can recover the entire claim cost from an unregistered employer. Every employer registration has a deadline, but only one is measured in single digits: the COIDA registration deadline of 7…
-
An Employee Was Injured Today: The First-24-Hours Protocol
⚡ Quick answer When an employee is injured at work, the first 24 hours follow a fixed protocol: get medical attention immediately, make the scene safe (and preserve it if the injury is serious), record the incident with witnesses and photos, notify the family where relevant, and start the two reporting clocks — the COIDA claim to the Compensation Fund within 7 days, and for serious incidents the OHS report to the Department inspector within 7 days. Keep paying the employee; for temporary total disablement the employer pays the first three months and claims it back from the Fund. The day an employee injured at work is the day your…
-
Letter of Good Standing Expired Before a Tender? The Rescue Drill
⚡ Quick answer A Letter of Good Standing that has expired or been refused almost always traces to one of three causes: an unfiled Return of Earnings, an unpaid assessment (often an estimated one raised after a missed return), or records sitting under the wrong entity. The rescue drill: pull your Compensation Fund account status, identify the exact gap, file the outstanding ROEs, let assessments be corrected, pay or arrange, then re-request the letter. Small gaps fix in days; multi-year gaps take weeks — start before the tender advert, not the week it closes. The tender closes Friday and the Letter of Good Standing is expired, refused, or was never…
-
COIDA ROE Season Opens 1 April: What to Prepare Now
⚡ Quick answer COIDA ROE season runs from 1 April to 31 May every year: every employer registered with the Compensation Fund must file a Return of Earnings declaring actual employee earnings for the year 1 March to end February, plus an estimate for the year ahead. Prepare three numbers before April: total earnings per employee for the assessment year, your headcount, and a realistic estimate for the coming year. Miss the window and the Fund estimates your earnings upward, adds penalties, and suspends your Letter of Good Standing. Every April, the COIDA ROE lands on the same desks as the EMP501 — and every May, a slice of employers…
-
SDL: What Happens When Your Payroll Crosses R500,000
⚡ Quick answer The Skills Development Levy (SDL) is 1% of your total payroll, payable only once your annual payroll exceeds R500,000. Cross the threshold and you register for SDL on the EMP101e (or add it to your existing SARS employer registration) and pay 1% monthly with your EMP201. The levy funds the SETA system — and employers who pay it can claim mandatory and discretionary grants back for training their own staff, which most small businesses never do. The Skills Development Levy is the payroll tax that arrives quietly: one growth spurt, a couple of new hires, and suddenly the payroll crosses R500,000 a year and SDL applies —…












