-
‘Resign or Be Fired’ Is a Legal Trap — Here Is What to Do Instead
⚡ Quick answer Telling an employee to ‘resign or be fired’ feels like a clean exit — but a resignation extracted under that pressure is legally a dismissal (constructive dismissal), and the employer then faces an unfair dismissal claim having run no fair process at all: no hearing, no warnings, no consultation. The employee has 30 days from the resignation to refer the dispute to the CCMA. The lawful alternatives are the ones the ultimatum was avoiding: a proper disciplinary process for misconduct, a performance process for poor performance, section 189 consultation for redundancy, or a genuine mutual separation agreement. ‘Just give them the choice — resign or be fired…


