-
‘Resign or Be Fired’ Is a Legal Trap — Here Is What to Do Instead
⚡ Quick answer Telling an employee to ‘resign or be fired’ feels like a clean exit — but a resignation extracted under that pressure is legally a dismissal (constructive dismissal), and the employer then faces an unfair dismissal claim having run no fair process at all: no hearing, no warnings, no consultation. The employee has 30 days from the resignation to refer the dispute to the CCMA. The lawful alternatives are the ones the ultimatum was avoiding: a proper disciplinary process for misconduct, a performance process for poor performance, section 189 consultation for redundancy, or a genuine mutual separation agreement. ‘Just give them the choice — resign or be fired…
-
Alternatives to Retrenchment You Must Consider First (Section 189)
⚡ Quick answer Section 189 consultation must genuinely explore alternatives to retrenchment before jobs are cut: a hiring freeze, reduced hours or short-time, voluntary severance packages, early retirement, redeployment to other roles, salary sacrifices by agreement, and transferring work in-house instead of retrenching. Commissioners ask for these by name — an employer who cannot show alternatives were tabled and considered has failed the consultation, whatever the severance paid. The exploration must be documented in the consultation minutes. The question commissioners ask first in retrenchment disputes is not about severance — it is ‘what alternatives to retrenchment did you explore?’ Section 189 makes job losses a last resort, and ‘last’ is…




